-------------------------------------------------------------
The Netherlands is one of a handful of countries where very ill people
have the right to medical assistance to kill themselves if they choose to
do so. But right-to-die advocates say that right should also be extended
to those who want to end their lives before the onset of illness and
incapacitation that comes with age.
A petition asking the Dutch parliament to debate whether all people over
70 have a right to suicide gathered more than 117,000 signatures. The
petition's sponsors hope to put it on the parliamentary agenda after
elections in June.
Assisted suicide is technically against the law in the Netherlands, but
there are exceptions. Doctors who assist with suicides cannot be punished
if they can prove they adhered to strict medical and ethical guidelines,
and if the patient was suffering from an "unbearable and hopeless" illness
and had explicitly and repeatedly requested the doctor's assistance in
dying.
But the Dutch organization De Einder, or Horizon, and other right-to-die
advocacy groups say that older individuals should be able to determine
when they want to end their own lives, even if they are not suffering from
serious illness. Instead, they should have the option of committing
suicide at a point where they consider their lives "complete."
[There are other related stories in the Links section below.]
[There are stories in the Overflow section below.]
To read the full article click on one of these links, both of which go to the same destination. A short link is provided for the convenience of readers. Also, readers may search and browse past and future advisories on the web (see bottom.)
http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,5627515,00.html
Also see:
Dutch citizens group argues "right to die" for over 70s
[EuthaNEWSia, Feb. 9, 2010]
http://www.euthanewsia.ca/archive/2010/02/enid201002093826.4.html
A citizens action group wants to legalize assisted
suicide for all people over 70, who have an
"explicit, logical and consistent" desire to end
their life. They say the task should be carried
out by a new kind of specially trained and
certified professional. The group, "Out of Free
Will", will start collecting signatures to lobby
for a change in legislation. A number of prominent
Dutch citizens have come out in support of the
initiative, including former ministers and
artists, legal scholars and physicians.
Fewer assisted suicides in the Netherlands by oral route
[World right-to-die news list]
http://lists.opn.org/pipermail/right-to-die_lists.opn.org/2010-May/003887.html
Suicide assisted by [Dutch] general practitioners often comes to pass by
drinking a deadly cocktail. Ten years ago it happened in 25% of the
cases. This percentage has dropped last year to 15. Researcher Annemieke
Horikx of the KNMP, the pharmacist association, mentioned this in
Medisch Contact, the periodical for general practitioners.
A general practitioner explained this decline is being caused by
pharmacists, who have to make the cocktail themselves. Often they don't
have the basic ingredients in stock, because the keeping date expires,
due to the minimal demand. So it is a vicious circle.
Dutch euthanasia laws now better reported
[World right-to-die news list]
http://lists.opn.org/pipermail/right-to-die_lists.opn.org/2010-May/003888.html
Researchers from the Dutch Research institute for Health Care, Nivel,
write in the general practitioners periodical The British Journal of
General Practice that the number of requests for euthanasia have not
increased since the euthanasia law came into existence. The number of
reports did increase, but not the requests to general practitioners.
‘It means that euthanasia does not happen more often, but that it is
reported more frequently’ says epidemiologist Ge Donker on the
Nivel-website `and this is good for the quality: better means are being
use in the correct dose.'
Siek, Stephanie. "Dutch groups want to expand assisted suicide rights". Deutsche Welle. 28.05.2010. <www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,5627515,00.html>. Deutsche Welle, D-53110 Bonn, Germany.
Tags (or keywords) briefly indicate some major topics of the report.
assisted suicide
euthanasia
NVVE, Right to Die - Netherlands
Of Free Will
Netherlands
Stories that EuthaNEWSia did not get to:
Wisconsin: Assisted suicide case asks: When is help criminal?
[Chicago Tribune]
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/chi-ap-wi-akillerssuicide,0,2498623.story
A Wisconsin inmate is expected to stand trial next month on allegations
that he helped his cellmate, a killer, commit suicide.
Joshua Walters could face up to 10 years in prison if convicted of
assisting in the January 2009 suicide of Adam Peterson.
Prosecutors say Walters encouraged Peterson to take his life and even
helped tie the noose from a bed sheet in their cell at the Dodge
Correctional Institute in Waupun.
Montana: Death With Dignity Declared A Choice
[KFBB.com]
http://www.kfbb.com/news/local/94982154.html
A news video interview on Montana's access to assisted suicide.
Barbara Coombs Lee: The Crime of Assisting a Suicide
[Huffington Post]
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/barbara-coombs-lee/the-crime-of-assisting-a_b_590847.html
Barbara Coombs Lee writes an opinion piece
extolling the virtues of assisting the suicide of
elderly patients in the final stages of terminal
illness, and decrying the vice of all other types
of assisted suicide. Coombs Lee conflates the
acts of persuading a person to commit suicide and
the act of assisting a person to commit suicide.
Four Moral Issues Sharply Divide Americans
[gallup.com]
http://www.gallup.com/poll/137357/Four-Moral-Issues-Sharply-Divide-Americans.aspx?utm_source=tagrss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=syndication&utm_term=Politics
The findings are from Gallup's annual
Values and Beliefs survey, conducted May 3-6, 2010.
While doctor-assisted suicide is the most
controversial of the issues tested, with the
public tied at 46% over its moral acceptability,
Americans are fairly unified in their opposition
to another life-ending choice — suicide — with 77% calling this morally wrong.
Dutch euthanasia laws now better reported
[World right-to-die news list]
http://lists.opn.org/pipermail/right-to-die_lists.opn.org/2010-May/003888.html
Researchers from the Dutch Research institute for Health Care, Nivel,
write in the general practitioners periodical The British Journal of
General Practice that the number of requests for euthanasia have not
increased since the euthanasia law came into existence. The number of
reports did increase, but not the requests to general practitioners.
‘It means that euthanasia does not happen more often, but that it is
reported more frequently’ says epidemiologist Ge Donker on the
Nivel-website `and this is good for the quality: better means are being
use in the correct dose.'
assisted suicide UK - Michael Bateman
[World right-to-die news list]
http://lists.opn.org/pipermail/right-to-die_lists.opn.org/2010-May/003889.html
Chris Docker of EXIT, Scotland, concludes an
overview of the Bateman case:
Change is most likely if their is a near consensus of public
opinion. The 'exceptions to the rule' method seems to be the way
things are going. Unfortunately, parliamentarians suggesting new
assisted suicide laws tend to put forward prescriptive measures
that alienate and polarise the populace. This can mean sympathetic
organisations are faced with the difficult dilemma of whether to
support a badly crafted law that 'means well.'
Britain: Laws on mercy killing questioned
[BBC News]
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/essex/8701835.stm
The eldest son of a woman convicted of
murdering her brain-damaged child has called for
changes in the law governing "mercy killing".
Frances Inglis, 57, injected a lethal shot of
heroin into her 22-year-old son Thomas in November
2008 after an earlier attempt had failed.
In an interview on BBC 5Live, Alex Inglis said his
mother had acted in Thomas' "best interest". He
explained that the family and Thomas' doctors were
discussing the possibility of applying to the
courts to have food and water withdrawn from him
to end his life but that he believed the process
was "cruel". He said his mother had acted to
spare Thomas from being "dehydrated to death".
Later, Inglis said: He said that he would
have considered ending Thomas' life himself if his
mother had not done so and suggested that the law
was failing to address the issue of mercy
killing.
Connecticut letter: Assisted suicide is my choice
[New Haven Register]
http://www.nhregister.com/articles/2010/05/22/opinion/doc4bf5f6fb40342864540973.txt
An extract from Carol Hummel's letter:
Unless you've cared for a loved one with Alzheimer's disease, you could
never understand the torment you both suffer. I cared for my beloved
mother in my home, and it was the hardest thing I've ever done in my
lifetime.
I have told my husband of 48 years I would not want my son to be
responsible for my care if I should be diagnosed with Alzheimer's. I would
hope my husband would have the courage to end my suffering.
I am strongly in favor of assisted suicide laws. I've worked in the
nursing field for 25 years, and witnessed abuse to patients who could not
speak or complain.
For me, assisted suicide is my choice. If I could have ended my
mother's suffering, I would have.
Connecticut: Editorial: North Haven deaths are the exception
[New Haven Register]
http://www.nhregister.com/articles/2010/05/28/opinion/doc4c00046af2529904545032.txt
The deaths of the Vanacores are being cited as an example of why the
state's law barring assisted suicide should be changed. It is, however,
more an example of what advocates for the disabled fear - that such a law
would be used to end their lives.
The doctors are asking the courts to make a decision that should be taken
by the legislature. But, the legislature has refused to act on amendments
to the 1969 law. Lawmakers inclined to change the law hope the courts will
rule first.
A favorable ruling would mean a fundamental change in the doctor-patient
relationship. Counseling or providing the means to commit suicide is a far
step beyond treating or curing a patient.
Assisted Suicide Shouldn't Be Option
[Hartford Courant]
http://www.courant.com/news/opinion/editorials/hc-digbrflets0522.artmay22,0,3831317.story
Nancy Ann Foley, a person with a disability,
writes opposing the legalization of assisted
suicide: Furthermore, it seems that
advocates for assisted suicide place physicians on
a pedestal as compassionate caregivers who can be
entrusted with the task of helping someone die. In
my experience, too many physicians are callous and
cause the disabled to suffer unnecessarily.
And Richard A. Castagno is living on his own and
driving, after recovering from a very serious
stroke. Castagno writes: I think Kathryn
Tucker, legal director for the national
end-of-life care advocacy group Compassion &
Choices, would say that my situation is not what
she's talking about. However, the first few days
after my stroke, I continued going downhill. The
prognosis was hopeless at best. If doctors had
been given the authority to withhold treatment
because my situations looked so bleak, would
compassion have dictated, in my case, that they
pull the plug?
The EuthaNEWSia ID for this advisory is: enid201005288174.
Mailed: Friday, May 28, 2010 14:33:29 -0600
at Saskatoon, Saskatchewan.
EuthaNEWSia is a free Canadian news advisory service covering end-of-life issues such as right to die, assisted suicide, and euthanasia. EuthaNEWSia is produced by the Right to Die Society of Canada which works toward a good death for all, including open, regulated and equitable access to euthanasia and assisted suicide. The editor is Michael Dawson <editor@euthanewsia.ca>.
-------------------------------------------------------------
EuthaNEWSia mailing list
euthanewsia-subscribe@euthanewsia.ca
You may leave the Subject blank and the message empty: the
server only reads the From address on the message.
euthanewsia-unsubscribe@euthanewsia.ca
You may leave the Subject blank and the message empty: the
server only reads the From address on the message.
-------------------------------------------------------------
see the recent headlines on the front page at www.euthanewsia.ca
see as-yet unpublished stories at the Pending Advisories page.
subscribe to the RSS News feed. More information is on the Subscribe page.
search the advisories on the search page.
browse and read past stories on the past stories page.
Problems? Send an email to: editor@euthanewsia.ca