-------------------------------------------------------------
The introduction to this opinion:
Nearly a quarter of a million Canadians die every year, most of them
elderly, as a result of chronic illnesses such as cancer, heart disease,
or Alzheimer's. Within a decade, that number will jump by nearly 100,000 a
year to an estimated 330,000.
Basic numbers about care for the terminally ill:
Despite the passions aroused by hospital-based euthanasia, much of the
care given to the terminally ill in Canada is provided by the dying
person's family or friends. In 2007, nearly a quarter of Canadians said
they had cared for a seriously ill family member or close friend in the
last 12 months. Many of these caregivers had to stop working and use
personal savings to survive.
Governments appear to be relying unfairly on unpaid caregivers. According
to data compiled by the Canadian Hospice Palliative Care Association, if
volunteer caregiving was paid for, it would cost Canadians between $25
billion and $28 billion a year.
The report ends with:
Unfortunately, in 2007, the Harper government disbanded the End-of-Life
Care Secretariat and no work on a national palliative and end-of-life
strategy seems to have been carried out since then. Underfunded and
uncoordinated, palliative care has become the orphan of the country's
medical system. It might well be because the system does not meet the
needs of dying Canadians, who want simply to die as pain-free as possible
and in their own homes, that the nightmare solution of euthanasia is
gaining a foothold.
[Note: EuthaNEWSia starts a two week summer break
today, with the next issue scheduled for Monday,
August 9th.]
[There are other related stories in the Links section below.]
[There are stories in the Overflow section below.]
To read the full article click on one of these links, both of which go to the same destination. A short link is provided for the convenience of readers. Also, readers may search and browse past and future advisories on the web (see bottom.)
http://www.montrealgazette.com/news/todays-paper/Canadians+prepared+inevitable/3311693/story.html
Also see:
Canadian Politicians Seek Positive Alternatives to Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide
[LifeSiteNews.com]
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2010/jul/10072305.html
OTTAWA, Ontario, July 23, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) Following
the sound defeat of a bill to legalize euthanasia and assisted
suicide in Canada's Parliament this spring, dozens of the
country's MPs — representing all parties — have come together
to address the root causes that lead some of Canada's
vulnerable to desire their own deaths.
"It's not enough simply to oppose assisted suicide and
euthanasia," said Harold Albrecht (Kitchener-Conestoga), the
Conservative co-chair of a new Parliamentary Committee on
Palliative and Compassionate Care (PCPCC). "We have to go
deeper than that and ask why people are even considering it. "
How can we improve the palliative care in our country so that
the question won't even need to be asked?"
The committee was announced in April, and already boasts a
membership of 40 MPs, representing every political party in
Canada. They are conducting hearings and public consultations
to seek ways to protect and care for Canada's vulnerable, and
are focusing their efforts on four major pillars: palliative
care, suicide prevention, elder abuse, and disability issues.
The committee began receiving submissions in May, and held
their first consultations in June. They plan to gather
information throughout the summer and fall with the aim of
presenting a report on their findings to the government and MPs
by the end of December, including specific recommendations on
how to address the issues they uncover.
Later in the article:
They decided to begin with a study of the reasons why people
would want to die or commit suicide. "It really boils down to,
in the end, a lack of hope, a lack of meaning and purpose for
their future," Albrecht suggested.
The committee's work is crucial to him, he said, "because I
believe in the value of life."
"Canadians ill-prepared for the inevitable". The Montreal Gazette. July 23, 2010. <www.montrealgazette.com/news/todays-paper/Canadians+prepared+inevitable/3311693/story.html>. The Gazette, 1010 Ste. Catherine St. West, Suite 200, Montreal, Quebec, H3B 5L1, CANADA.
Tags (or keywords) briefly indicate some major topics of the report.
death
palliative care
end-of-life care
terminally ill
euthanasia
Canada
Stories that EuthaNEWSia did not get to:
A Final Prescription
[The New York Times]
http://newoldage.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/07/16/a-final-prescription/
This article explains the basics of
P.O.L.S.T. ("physician orders for life-sustaining
treatment".) A POLST is a short form of specific
medical instructions used by patients with serious
illness who are approaching death. Advance
Directives may be created years in advance, and so
may contain general terms, and be quite long.
POLSTs are created for imminent need, and so can
be short and specific, which has advantages. For
example, ambulance staff will obey treatment
instructions on a POLST, where they would not have
time to read and interpret an advance directive.
But POLSTs are only recognized in regions that
have officially adopted them — a great deal of
education and coordination is needed before POLSTs
become useful. The POLST web site
(http://www.ohsu.edu/polst/) has information on
availability in the U.S.A. My Google search does
not produce information on any Canadian
jurisdiction that has POLSTs in use.
Tasmania: Police drop death inquiry
[The Mercury]
http://www.themercury.com.au/article/2010/07/19/159785_tasmania-news.html
The news was welcomed yesterday by Attorney-General Lara Giddings and
Greens leader Nick McKim, who said their proposed new laws to legalise
euthanasia would end confusion for police, doctors and families.
Voluntary euthanasia advocate and Melbourne doctor Rodney Syme was
investigated by Tasmania Police over the death of Allens Rivulet man Rob
Cordover.
Mr Cordover, also a passionate supporter of euthanasia, died surrounded by
his family in June last year after a nine-month battle with motor neurone
disease.
Dr Syme admitted helping Mr Cordover to take his life by giving him advice
and medication.
His admissions to the Mercury last year prompted Kingston detective Scott
Kregor to travel to Melbourne to interview Dr Syme.
But Det Sgt Kregor told the Mercury last week he would not be taking
further action.
[Thanks to
Dying with
Dignity New South Wales for the alert on this
story.]
Wisconsin: Physician, Alzheimer's-stricken wife commit suicide
[Journal Sentinel]
http://www.jsonline.com/news/milwaukee/99074314.html
A few days before he committed suicide with his wife of 53 years, Daniel
Gute, a retired physician, wrote a note explaining their mutual decision
to die.
The two-page handwritten letter is dated July 16, and it is signed by both
Gute and his wife, Katherine, whom he calls "Kitty." Kitty Gute had been
diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease more than a year before.
The note describes Kitty Gute's failing health, daily indignities and
chronic pain. It touches on their determination not to allow the vibrant
life they had shared come to an end in a nursing home, where they feared
their deaths would be no better than dragged out and wrested from their
control.
"I am hoping that sometime this weekend I will have the guts to act to
deliver us both from a more dismal situation," he writes.
"I have been thinking about this for a long time. It will not be easy.
However, as time goes by it will not get any better."
One of their three daughters, Mary Witte, found Daniel and Kitty Gute's
bodies Sunday.
The two were inclined toward each other in the front seat of Kitty Gute's
car, which was parked in the garage of their River Hills home. They had
asphyxiated themselves with helium, an inert gas they pumped into plastic
bags that covered their heads.
Kitty Gute was 78. Daniel Gute would have turned 80 on Aug. 4.
Later in the report:
The notes indicate that the Gutes struggled not so much with decision to
kill themselves, but rather when.
Daniel Gute feared that he would grow too frail to carry out their
decision or that Kitty Gute's dementia would progress to a point that it
would obliterate her ability to form will or intent.
Britain: Tonbridge mother backs right-to-die campaign
[BBC News]
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-10746703
A 29-year-old mother who has been locked inside her
body for the past two years has said she believes the law should
be changed to allow people in her situation to die, even though
she believes she has a lot to live for.
Tracey Senik, from Tonbridge, can only move her eyes - a condition that
followed an accident when she was doing cartwheels with her daughter.
Britain: Inglis: "Mercy killing" case adjourned
[BBC Blogs]
http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/ferguswalsh/2010/07/inglis_mercy_killing_case_adjourned.html
Fergus Walsh writes:
The Lord Chief Justice and two fellow High Court judges were there to hear
an application by Frances Inglis against her murder conviction. The judges
were ready and the case was set down for the whole day. Ready too were the
barristers and solicitors for the Crown and the defence.
The only person not ready was the applicant herself. A letter emerged
yesterday in which Frances Inglis stated she wanted alternative counsel -
effectively sacking her legal team.
Inglis had been found guilty in January of the murder and attempted murder
of her brain-damaged son, Thomas. She injected him with heroin because she
said she wanted to release him from a "living hell".
Speaking from behind the bars of the dock today, Inglis told Lord Judge,
"I don't feel I'll get a fair hearing if it goes ahead now. There are a
lot of issues I'd like you to consider regarding the trial and it would be
sad if that was denied."
The judges agreed to adjourn her application for permission to appeal
against conviction, but no new court date was set.
Edinburgh Pensioner Sentenced in Attempted Murder of Disabled Wife
[LifeSiteNews.com]
http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2010/jul/10072201.html
During his trial for attempted murder, an Edinburgh
pensioner told the court that he thought killing his disabled
wife by smothering her with a pillow would "be a good thing to
do" "for both of us." The Edinburgh High Court found John
Millar, 67, guilty of attempted murder last week and has
sentenced him to four and half years in prison. His
wheelchair-bound wife, Phyllis Millar, has suffered from Multiple
Sclerosis for 20 years and Millar was her primary caregiver. He
pleaded guilty to charges of attempted murder.
Lady Justice Smith told Millar, *You quite deliberately tried
to kill her. Fortunately, your wife was able to get one of her
hands between her face and the pillow so as to enable her to
breathe and to shout for you to stop.
"Had she not been able to shout at you, it does not seem that
your attempt to murder her would have stopped when it did."
The prosecuting attorney said that Phyllis "was quite clear
throughout this investigation that she had not at any stage
told the accused that she wanted her life to end, and had never
requested his assistance to help her to die."
New Zealand: Doctor refutes claims of patient euthanasia
[tvnz.co.nz]
http://tvnz.co.nz/national-news/doctor-refutes-claims-patient-euthanasia-3666143
A specialist who has worked with geriatric patients for two decades, has
said he has never seen any doctor perform euthanasia.
On Tuesday night's Close Up programme Dr John Pollock, who is terminally
ill, claimed many doctors are already practising euthanasia.
"It's called pain control or anxiety control, but the reality is many of
the doctors who do this are deliberately shortening the lifespan of the
patient, quite rightly," claimed Pollock.
But on Breakfast today, Professor Martin Connolly from North Shore
Hospital's geriatric unit, said he has never known of it.
"Clearly there has to be a distinction made between active euthanasia -
that is, bringing a patient's life to an end on purpose… and a person
deciding not to have active treatment because they believe that treatment
would be futile. But that is not the same as active euthanasia," Connolly
told Pippa Wetzell.
"If patients decline treatment, then that's something we respect. But in
terms of ending a patient's life on purpose, that is not something I have
ever come across."
USA: Euthanasia Billboards, Books Fight for Death on Your Own Terms
[ABC News]
http://abcnews.go.com/Health/MindMoodNews/billboards-advertise-death-terms/story?id=11164242
On the Final Exit Network billboards:
Mixed in among the billboards for radio stations and fast food restaurants
in San Francisco and New Jersey are controversial roadside ads appealing
to the seriously ill who want help in committing suicide.
Emblazoned with the slogan "My Life. My Death. My Choice," the black
billboards are part of a larger campaign by the Final Exit Network to spur
discussion and raise awareness of what it considers the inalienable right
to die with dignity.
While many right-to-die advocates argue for the legalization of
physician-assisted suicide for the terminally ill, Final Exit Network
offers "exit guidance" to those with serious but not necessarily terminal
illnesses, allowing them to take their death into their own hands, either
with a physician's help or not.
On the distribution of Final Exit to libraries:
Final Exit Network's philosophy is soon to get even more exposure, thanks
to an anonymous $50,000 deathbed donation to the like-minded Euthanasia
Research and Guidance Organization, headed by Derek Humphry, who founded
the assisted-suicide movement in the U.S. and wrote "Final Exit," a
do-it-yourself guide to assisted suicide.
The $50,000 donation was made with the express purpose of supplying as
many public libraries as possible with Humphry's book. So far, 2,000
copies of "Final Exit" have been sent to libraries around the country.
"No library has not wanted to carry the book. We've been getting thank-you
letters," Humphry says.
The July 2010 issue of The Voice is available.
[Dying With Dignity Canada]
http://dwdcanada.blogspot.com/2010/07/below-is-link-to-our-july-2010-issue-of.html
The focus of this issue is on our Annual General Meeting, held on June 05
in Toronto, with summaries of most presentations and questions asked.
We were happy to have had almost 60 members attend our AGM - however, many
more were not able to attend. For those who were not in attendance, we
hope you find this summary full and inclusive of topics discussed at the
three hour meeting.
If you were among the members at the AGM, there is also new information
for you in this 8 page issue: new Canadian cancer statistics,
international news, new Canadian polls, book reviews and more.
[A PDF of The Voice is available from a link on the above web
page.]
The EuthaNEWSia ID for this advisory is: enid201007237193.
Mailed: Friday, July 23, 2010 14:46:42 -0600
at Saskatoon, Saskatchewan.
EuthaNEWSia is a free Canadian news advisory service covering end-of-life issues such as right to die, assisted suicide, and euthanasia. EuthaNEWSia is produced by the Right to Die Society of Canada which works toward a good death for all, including open, regulated and equitable access to euthanasia and assisted suicide. The editor is Michael Dawson <editor@euthanewsia.ca>.
-------------------------------------------------------------
EuthaNEWSia mailing list
euthanewsia-subscribe@euthanewsia.ca
You may leave the Subject blank and the message empty: the
server only reads the From address on the message.
euthanewsia-unsubscribe@euthanewsia.ca
You may leave the Subject blank and the message empty: the
server only reads the From address on the message.
-------------------------------------------------------------
see the recent headlines on the front page at www.euthanewsia.ca
see as-yet unpublished stories at the Pending Advisories page.
subscribe to the RSS News feed. More information is on the Subscribe page.
search the advisories on the search page.
browse and read past stories on the past stories page.
Problems? Send an email to: editor@euthanewsia.ca